No women near the small Minnesota tourist town have been reported missing; No women near the small Minnesota tourist town have been reported missing; because the victim's face is damaged, she can't be identified without the help of a forensic artist. She finally is recognized as Sarah Yoder, a young Amish woman, the police have difficulty investigating the case because the Amish believe in forgiveness rather than prosecution. When Riley finds a clue the cops miss, she uncovers a dark web of fraud and deception in the community - driven by motives as old as the Bible.